Wedding Cakes · Blacklick, Ohio

Cookie Momster House

LGBTQ+-owned bakery in Blacklick, Ohio, making custom wedding cakes, cookies and desserts.

Cookie Momster House is a bakery in Blacklick, Ohio, on the east side of the Columbus area. It specializes in customized cakes and cookies and can design a flavor profile from scratch or recreate a traditional cake you already have in mind.

An LGBTQ+-owned bakery

Cookie Momster House is LGBTQ+-owned. For couples planning a same-sex wedding in central Ohio, that means ordering a cake from a team that will not ask who the groom is or pause over two toppers. You can focus on flavor, shape and color.

What the bakery makes

The range goes beyond cake. The bakers make cupcakes, pies, baklava, brownies, candies, cookies and bars.

  • Multi-tiered cakes
  • Small cutting cakes for intimate weddings
  • Cupcakes, pies and brownies
  • Custom cookies and candies
  • Baklava and bars

Ordering a wedding dessert

Start by deciding whether the cake is a centerpiece or a cutting ceremony piece, with sheet cake or desserts for guests. A small cutting cake plus cookies can be economical and still photogenic.

Ask about tasting options, deposits, delivery to your venue and who sets up the display. Tell the bakers about allergies, gluten needs or vegan guests so they can plan. Bring pictures of color palettes, florals or stationery so the design matches the rest of the day.

Timing

Order several months ahead for a wedding weekend. Confirm whether the venue has refrigeration and a stable table, since heat and a bumpy ride can damage frosting.

Frequently asked

Can I get something other than cake?

Yes. The bakery lists cupcakes, pies, baklava, brownies, candies, cookies and bars.

Can the cake be fully customized?

The bakers say they can design a unique flavor profile or make a traditional cake, so describe what you want.

More wedding cakes in Ohio

A lesbian couple on honeymoon in the Maldives

Our sister brand

After the wedding, the honeymoon

Out Of Office plans tailor-made honeymoons for LGBTQ+ couples, with hotels and guides chosen for how they welcome you.

Plan your honeymoon