Crispin Hill

Crispin Hill is a wedding venue on a former apple orchard above Keuka Lake in the Finger Lakes, about three miles from Penn Yan. The nine-acre hillside has lake views, a renovated barn, a pavilion and a century-old farmhouse.

Why it suits LGBTQ+ couples

It is a strong fit for couples who want a full wedding in one place, run by a dedicated team and built around your own plans. The venue describes a menu tailored to each couple, which suits celebrations that do not follow a template. A private lakeside ceremony spot and an on-site suite mean you can keep the whole day, from getting ready to the last dance, within one property.

Ceremonies

The ceremony site sits beside the lake. A softly lit path leads there from the barn, so guests can walk down together as the light changes. The setting is outdoors, so it is worth talking through a weather plan with the team when you book.

Receptions and food

Receptions take place in the Crispin Barn and the pavilion next to it. The barn is climate controlled, and a cocktail lounge sits alongside. Together the barn and pavilion hold up to 160 guests. An in-house executive chef cooks classic dishes from seasonal, regional ingredients, and the bar offers signature cocktails. The venue also keeps a curated list of vendors for the parts it does not provide.

Staying

The Crispin Farm House is a restored home more than a century old. It works as a wedding suite, with a principal suite, a marble bathroom with a claw foot tub, a chef kitchen and a roomy deck. It is a calm place to get ready with your people.

Getting there and the area

Crispin Hill is on the shore of Keuka Lake, a short drive from Penn Yan. Rochester and Syracuse are the larger cities within reach, and the Finger Lakes wine country is on the doorstep for guests who want to explore. Ask the team for directions and for local places to stay.

Good to know

• Barn and pavilion hold up to 160 guests.
• The ceremony site is lakeside, reached by a lit path.
• Dates for 2027 were open at the time of research, with 2028 bookings due to open in September 2026.